For some reason women will never forget the person who gave them a crappy wedding gift. The NY Times caught-up with women ten years after the fact and asked them if they still remember who gave them a crappy wedding gift and the majority said yes. You could speak to a 98 year old woman and she couldn't remember the song they danced to but she could remember the bad present.
Slacker got a used waffle iron (it still had pancake batter on it) as a wedding gift!
Are you still holding a grudge against the crappy gift giver? How bad was the gift?